Five NYC Tenant Laws Your Landlord Doesn’t Want You to Know
Get acquainted with some of the stranger tenant laws on the books in NYC
It’s not beyond New York City landlords to try to evict their tenants for their own personal gain. But in recent years, the city government and the courts have started to come down hard on all kinds of shady practices by landlords. Of course, that doesn’t you shouldn’t get yourself acquainted with all the quirky rules and clauses out there in the great big world of NYC’s housing laws.
Here are five you might have heard of, and how they may work to your advantage.
5) You can totally get around that No Pets clause in the lease.
According to NYC Admin. Code § 27-2009.1(b), “In multiple dwellings in New York City and Westchester County, a no-pet lease clause is deemed waived where a tenant ‘openly and notoriously’ kept a pet for at least three months and the owner of the building or the owner’s agent had knowledge of this fact.”
Lawyer Adam Leitman Bailey writes, “Even the most casual observations by the landlord’s workers, not necessarily of the pets themselves, but of the pets’ accoutrements, have been held to bind the landlord to knowledge of the pet being kept ‘openly and notoriously.’ … There is no way to write a no-pet clause in a lease to avoid these issues.” So, basically, if you walk by a maintenance worker holding a leash, then wait three months, you can have a dog.
Landlords also may not prohibit tenants from owning a service animal, whether it’s a guide dog or one used for emotional support—but be prepared to provide documentation about it if asked.
4) There are some apartments you can just live in for free (or at least, somewhat affordably) forever.
In the summer of 2012, artist Margaret Maugenest won a case against her landlord where he was trying to evict her after she refused to pay rent for nine years. Her apartment, a Gowanus loft for which she had previous been paying $600/month, had not been brought up to code nor had the landlord filed for an extension under the 1982 Loft Law and the State Court of Appeals ruled that Maugenest did not have to leave or pay the rent.
This doesn’t mean that you’ll have the same luck as Maugenest, however, but the Loft Law does afford tenants in mostly commercial or industrial buildings more protections than you’d think.
3) If your landlord won’t let you have roommates, just marry them.
The roommates, not the landlord. Don’t try to marry your landlord. (Well, you can, but it doesn’t guarantee you a rent reduction or anything.) According to the guidelines of Real Property Law § 235-f, “It is unlawful for a landlord to restrict occupancy of an apartment to the named tenant in the lease or to that tenant and immediate family.”
2) It is very difficult to evict someone for chronic nonpayment.
Although chronic nonpayment, in which a tenant regularly pays rent more than a month late, is technically grounds for getting evicted, according to Bailey, “When one examines the case law with regard to chronic nonpayment, the only thing really clear is that there is no clear set of standards. ‘Occasional’ late payments are not enough to sustain the proceeding.” So, even if you rarely pay your rent on time, legally you’re probably good. (Not that we recommend actually doing that or anything.)
1) Elevators have to have mirrors.
Per Multiple Dwelling Law § 51-b; NYC Admin. Code § 27-2042, “There must be a mirror in each self-service elevator in multiple dwellings so that people may see, prior to entering, if anyone is already in the elevator.” We’re not sure how you can use this one to your advantage, but you’re welcome to try. “I haven’t paid rent in nine years? Well the elevators don’t have mirrors. They are legally required to have mirrors!”
Curbed New York, June 15, 2017