Reference#:44543 Page 1 of 1
THE CITY OF NEW YORK ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL BOARD
Location: 144-06 94th Avenue, Main Floor, Jamaica, NY 11435, (718)298-7300
Method of Appearance: AT HEARING
Place of Occurrence: —–
Hearing Date: 10/20/2009
Violation Number: 034568664R
City of New York vs —–
Issuing Officer: ST. ROSE, D.
Agency: DEPARTMENT OF BUILDINGS
TO: ADAM LEITMAN BAILEY, P.C.
120 BROADWAY APT#: 17TH FL
NEW YORK, NY 10271
A Notice of Violation was duly served, charging that on: 2/21/2007, at, the Respondent violated the below infraction(s).
The Respondent appeared and entered the plea(s) indicated below, and a hearing was held before me on the above-cited date.
On the Record before me, I find:
DISMISSAL: For the reasons stated below, the Notice of Violation is dismissed.
Infra. Code| Section/Description
BBQ2 AC. 27-147 WORK WITHOUT A PERMIT: HAZARDOUS
Plea| Disposition| Reason| Penalty
Deny Dismissed 8 $0.00
FURTHER FINDINGS OF FACT/CONCLUSIONS OF LAW:
Adam Bailey and Pete Reid represented the respondent and denied the violation of work without a permit in the installation of water and waste lines for a three-piece bathroom, residential sink, and a gas line for a stove.
Mr. Bailey questioned service, in that reasonable efforts were not made to effect service. The superintendent at the building appeared, stating that he was at the building the entire day, and was not served. He stated that he picked the notice of violation off the door a few days after, the violation issued. Mr. Bailey also questioned mail service. Building Department Representative Pena reviewed DOB records and found that mail service was effected at the place of occurrence, and furnished printouts to substantiate this.
Mr. Bailey questioned the superintendent, who stated that he began working at the place of occurrence in 1987 which was prior to the transfer of this property to the cited respondent, and at that time, there was this unit used by doorman, porter, etc. as a temporary rest area.
Credible testimony of pre-existing condition. i.e., the apartment was installed prior to the transfer of the property to the named respondent, warrants dismissal of the violation.
CIVIL PENALTY: I order the Respondent to pay a total of: $0.00
In addition, I order the Respondent to perform the Compliance Order(s), if any, listed above.
Signature of Administrative Law Judge Date
ALJ Name: BALSAMO, DOLORES
Date Mailed: DEC 09 2009
PAYMENTS DUE WITHIN 10 DAYS
READ BACK OF THIS ORDER-PROTECT YOUR RIGHTS
ECB V-F (10/17/08)(R3)